top of page

When Good Intentions Domesticate a Good Program

Oct 15
11 min read

I recently watched a first-grade literacy lesson that illustrates a challenge I see in classrooms across the US.


The teacher cared deeply about her students. She wanted them to feel loved and safe in addition to understanding and succeeding with the content. Every choice she made came from good intentions.


Yet, a phonics lesson that should have taken 45 to 50 minutes ended up taking 90, which crowded out time that should have been spent on reading comprehension.


The literacy block was scheduled for 110 minutes because the school is on a 4-day week and is trying to accommodate 5 days of curriculum into 4 days of learning. However, a social-emotional learning segment ran long and the block started late. Then the phonics lesson stretched to fill everything that was left.


When good intentions domesticate a good program. Image graphically illustrates how a seven step phonics lesson was stretched and altered.

What domestication looks like

I use the word domesticate on purpose. This school's core program comes from a major, well-known publisher. It isn't perfect, but it is designed well enough that it should never have been altered to this degree. Its slides and lesson plan are built around a seven-step phonics lesson model:

Thumbnail of author's phonics lesson outline.
Learn more: Here's a copy of my Seven-Step Structured Literacy (phonics) Lesson Framework

1.     Review of previous concepts

2.     Phonological or phonemic awareness warm-up

3.     Introduction of the new concept

4.     Blending words that include the new concept

5.     Spelling words that include the new concept

6.     High-frequency words connected to the decodable text

7.     A fully decodable text for practice reading connected text with the new concept

 


This teacher took every one of those steps off the program's slides and rebuilt them on teacher-created slides, with different fonts than the materials the kids were learning from. The font choice (Comic Sans) was likely selected because there is popular opinion suggesting it supports students with dyslexia, but to my knowledge there is no strong evidence to back that claim. The font looked fun and friendly, but it broke the consistency the program was designed around.


Some steps survived. Some were added to. Some disappeared.


The phonological awareness warm-up never happened at all.


The new concept was introduced before the lesson even started and then repeated later.


Students practiced previous sound spelling patterns without explicit connections to the Sound Spelling Cards that are intended to be the multisensory anchor for student learning.


Where the lesson went astray

Unnecessary teacher effort. The teacher changed every single lesson element of the core program by creating her own slides and techniques. I can only imagine how much time that took her to prepare. It was an unnecessary preparation task that broke the lesson design and likely cost her significant personal time outside of work.


Teacher talk. The introduction to open and closed syllables was clear, but it went on far longer than the program recommends and was repeated at two different points – both before the lesson began and again midstream in the lesson. It was as if the teacher thought that the kids had to fully master the concept right then, instead of being introduced to it and practicing it over and over in the other lesson steps. During the rest of the lesson steps, the teacher talked and talked. The kids barely did. While the kids were attentive, that’s not the point of a phonics lesson. I’d say the ratio of teacher talk to student talk was about 9 to 1. Students only read and discussed briefly before the teacher would give extended discussion of vocabulary or other concepts.  


Vocabulary instead of phonics. As a phonics lesson, students should be getting significant practice reading. In this case, reading multisyllabic words with open and closed syllables. After students blended a word, which took about ten seconds, she put up several pictures and spent 45 seconds to a minute discussing the vocabulary meaning of each word they read. The activities would have been good for vocabulary building, but that’s not the right moment. It should have been explicit phonics practice. A lesson and routine meant to build automaticity with phonics concepts became a vocabulary lesson, and the automaticity practice with phonics was lost.


Spelling without meaning and proper modeling. English orthography has a sound (phoneme) layer and also a meaning layer (morpheme). It is a morphophonemic spelling system. Good spellers use sounds, syllables, and morphemic understanding to spell words. So good routines ensure students understand meaning and break words into syllables or word parts, spelling the parts one by one. Even though I had demonstrated all of these elements of good spelling instruction, the teacher didn’t provide either meaning (via a sentence) or syllable by syllable spelling. While the teacher had the students clap the syllables, they went straight to counting sounds in the whole multisyllabic word, six or seven of them, instead of working one syllable at a time, which is how good spellers think. So, they had nothing to hang a tricky spelling on in terms of the morphemic background and they had to hold the full word in their memory rather than chunking it as a good speller would. 


Unnecessary high-frequency words and too much time. High-frequency words are best taught as a connection to the decodable text to prepare students for reading, not as random words to learn. Also, high-frequency word instruction should be quick so that students can get to the task of reading their decodable texts to practice reading. The teacher changed the lesson design and handed out a worksheet that wasn't from the curriculum at all which had extra words. Only one of the three words from the worksheet appeared in the decodable text the kids read later. The teacher had the students read the words with her, then code them for what was irregular. That part was fine. But then she had the students walk around for a few minutes “reading” the three words as they walked around the class. When I looked at students’ eyes, very few of them were actually on the paper. They were just walking, holding the paper, and saying the three words over and over from memory, not reading. The teacher repeated a second version of the sight word analysis task after they were done, which was the result of her domesticating the lesson. It had redundant elements in it.


A decodable text nobody decoded. The whole point of decodable text is to practice, practice, practice the skill introduced that day. Students should have repeated readings of the decodable text. Instead, she put one sentence at a time on a teacher-created slide, added two to three pictures of her own, talked about the pictures, read the sentence aloud, and had the students echo her. One of the target words in the text was muffin (a word for students to practice closed syllables). Up came a picture of a muffin, the teacher talked about the muffin, and the teacher read the sentence with the muffin. The kids didn't have to apply their skills. They only had to remember the pictures and parrot the teacher. This happened with every single sentence in the decodable text (which the program had designed without any pictures). When children learn to lean on pictures and context instead of the print, it undermines learning to decode. A child who can say "muffin" because there is a muffin on the screen hasn't decoded anything.

With a decodable, yes, I want students to practice accurate reading. Pictures aren’t bad in and of themselves. However, a strong decodable routine gives students the chance to decode the text on their own before choral reading with the teacher. Everything about the changes made to this lesson undermined the instructional intent of having a decodable text.


Why the design matters

A well-designed program is not a collection of suggestions. Each routine is there for a reason, and the research explains the reason.


Explicit, systematic phonics instruction matters, and we know what it needs to look like. In the National Reading Panel (2000) meta-analysis of phonics studies, systematic phonics instruction beat every comparison approach, including whole language, with an overall effect size of 0.41 (page 2-112).


Rosenshine’s (2012) Principles of Instruction, drawn from cognitive science, studies of master teachers, and research on cognitive supports, describe the types of instructional moves a good routine builds in: begin with a short review, present new material in small steps with student practice after each step, and ask many questions so you can check the responses of all students. In this lesson, the kids themselves did very little talking comparatively. And even though the steps were roughly in the right order, they were constantly interrupted by other unrelated tasks, specifically the repeated vocabulary development. Also, the student practice opportunities were not focused in ways that enabled the teacher to check whether student responses reflected actual learning or simply the scaffolding and repetition the teacher provided.

 

Clark, Kirschner, and Sweller (2012) summarize how the research shows that novice learners need explicit guidance with practice and feedback, which is more effective and efficient than partial guidance, because working memory is very limited for new information and novices don’t yet have the stored knowledge experts draw on. The teacher I observed likely thought she was giving more explicit guidance as she built vocabulary, for example, but the multiple detours from phonics into other topics actually meant that the guidance and practice was sporadic, not explicit. A well-designed program is built around explicitness that deepens through the course of the lesson. Rebuilding a lesson in its entirety introduces multiple opportunities that risk undermining the explicit design it was created to use.

 

This is bigger than one teacher

I'm not telling this story to pick on a teacher. The teacher I saw is a wonderful human who values her students and wants the absolute best for them. She’s had Science of Reading and dyslexia training that includes good ideas and strong theoretical underpinning, although it was delivered without guidance on how to apply it while staying faithful to the intent of her district’s adopted core reading program.


I see versions of this all the time. Teachers take ideas they hear, filter them through their own lens, and then bolt them onto their existing core programs or use those ideas to replace their core programs without really understanding the damage they are doing to instructional design.


The Sold a Story podcast series by Emily Hanford provides a lot of insight into why this happens.


In 2022, Season 1 (How Teaching Kids To Read Went So Wrong) traced how a flawed idea about reading spread through schools. The US education system has experienced decades of poor philosophy and instruction in early literacy because people followed popular ideas that didn’t work, but that many fiercely defended. Season 1 did a great job shining light on how ineffective reading instruction spread and what the research says about effective literacy instruction. It fueled a renewed interest in the Science of Reading that has taken off in the years since.


Season 2 launched in 2026 and asks what happened to teaching itself. It’s extremely enlightening. In a nutshell, it comes back to people’s beliefs about what works…not what actually works. There is a huge disparity between evidence and practice in many cases.


For example, Episode 3 revisits Project Follow Through, the federal experiment that compared 22 instructional models to see what would be most effective. As the episode tells it, Zig Engelmann's Direct Instruction was the only one to show positive results on every category measured. However, the government never promoted the findings. Early data was withheld from the public, and after the 1977 final evaluation, a critique co-written by Gene Glass, who found nothing “special or worthy of wide distribution,” helped stop the government from endorsing it. It then shifted money to models that had not done well. Now decades later, with additional evidence supporting the effectiveness of Direct Instruction, detractors still criticize it based on opinions instead of evidence. Episode 5 covers a meta-analysis of more than 300 studies on the topic, showing an average effect size of .54 (Stockard et al. 2018), yet the approach never caught on widely in American schools.


Episode 6, "Get Ready!", asks why schools keep giving up on Direct Instruction. The episode names two reasons schools drop it. Training, observation, and coaching erode when leaders turn over or grant money ends. And many teachers were taught in college to design their own lessons, so a designed routine feels like a threat to their professionalism.


To be clear, the program in this classroom isn't Engelmann's Direct Instruction. However, it is built on related principles that have made their way into common early literacy curricula: clear, explicit, carefully sequenced teaching is how beginners learn best.


Also, I'm not advocating that everyone go out and buy the formal Direct Instruction (capital DI) curriculum. I am advocating, however, that the principles of direct instruction (lower case DI) are effective and are at the core of what we mean by "explicit, systematic phonics instruction."


I have given the teachers in this school training. I’ve met with their PLCs to explain the foundations of explicit, systematic phonics instruction and how it maps to their core program. About two months ago, I even modeled in this teacher's classroom the types of explicit routines and lesson design that the evidence supports.


However, it seems like everything that I had shared and modeled had been set aside in favor of her beliefs about what instruction should look like. Her program was already built around direct teaching of concepts, and she reworked it anyway. I don't think that's defiance per se. I think it's what she was taught…the belief that she as an individual teacher needs to customize everything based on her professional judgment.


Her talent is real, but it is better suited for her warmth toward students, her pacing, her read of the room, and how she delivers evidence-based lessons and routines…not in redesigning the lessons and routines that evidence has proven to work.


What I'd recommend for literacy leaders

  1. Know the design. Principals and literacy coaches should understand the design of an explicit, systematic phonics lesson (a key aspect of a structured literacy approach), be able to say what each step is for, and observe against the program's own set of instructional routines, not a generic walk-through form.

  2. Coach routines, not just materials. Model specific instructional routines, explain their purpose, be precise about student cueing and response procedures. Then, watch teachers, give feedback, and repeat. Fidelity erodes when teachers don’t understand the purpose, precision, and power of the instructional routines that they are taught.

  3. Protect the reading block. Minutes add up. I had shown the district that their previous reading block was scheduled for only about half of the core program’s expected 16,200 minutes of planned instruction over the course of each year. The district corrected that by expanding the reading block, but now time was lost due to teacher decisions. When something else runs long, literacy minutes (and outcomes) shrink. Decide in advance what gives and what does not.

  4. Add structure, don't rebuild. If a program has real weaknesses, fix them deliberately and systematically, while keeping the instructional intent. Adaptation should start from understanding the design, not replacing it.


Good intentions matter. I want teachers who care about kids and make them feel loved, safe, respected, and joyful. But for a first grader, loved and respected also means a lesson that is crisp, clear, and fast-paced, with plenty of chances to say the sounds, read the words, and spell them. Many of the kids in this room were successful. The ones who need explicitness most were probably left with gaps.


Domesticating a program doesn't make it friendlier for students. It makes it something else.


I love watching a well-run instructional routine where teachers understand how to use the principles of direct, clear instruction. It makes me sad when I see such major examples of domestication that undermine explicit phonics instruction. Our kids deserve better.







References

Clark, R. E., Kirschner, P. A., & Sweller, J. (2012). Putting students on the path to learning: The case for fully guided instruction. American Educator, 36(1), 6–11.

Hanford, E. (Host). (2022). Sold a Story: How teaching kids to read went so wrong [Audio podcast]. APM Reports. https://features.apmreports.org/sold-a-story/

Hanford, E. (Host). (2026, October 22). The forgotten experiment (Season 2, Episode 3) [Audio podcast episode]. In Sold a Story. APM Reports. https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2026/10/22/sold-a-story-s2-e3-the-forgotten-experiment

Hanford, E. (Host). (2026, November 5). Why it works (Season 2, Episode 5) [Audio podcast episode]. In Sold a Story. APM Reports. https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2026/11/05/sold-a-story-s2-e5-why-it-works

Hanford, E. (Host). (2026, November 12). Get ready! (Season 2, Episode 6) [Audio podcast episode]. In Sold a Story. APM Reports. https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2026/11/12/sold-a-story-s2-e6-get-ready

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the National Reading Panel: Teaching children to read: An evidence-based assessment of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for reading instruction (NIH Publication No. 00-4769). U.S. Government Printing Office.

Rosenshine, B. (2012). Principles of instruction: Research-based strategies that all teachers should know. American Educator, 36(1), 12–19, 39.

Stockard, J., Wood, T. W., Coughlin, C., & Khoury, C. R. (2018). The effectiveness of Direct Instruction curricula: A meta-analysis of a half century of research. Review of Educational Research, 88(4), 479–507. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654317751919

 
 
bottom of page